MetLife Your Life logo  

Ask your question:  editor@MetLifeYourLife.com

Is Your Home Underinsured?

The truth is that two out of three U.S. homes don't have enough insurance coverage in case of disaster. Find out if yours is one of them.


You check the balance on your 401(k) regularly and watch the ups and downs of the stock market on CNN. But when was the last time you checked whether the insurance on your home -- which may be worth more than all your savings accounts combined -- was adequate? About 59 percent of U.S. homes are undervalued by an average of 22 percent, according to Marshall & Swift/Boeckh, a company that tracks building costs. That can add up to serious financial trouble. See if you fit into one of these common categories of underinsured homeowners.

THE REMODELERS
Elizabeth and Jonathan Ray might as well call the home improvement store in Savannah, Georgia, their second home. In 2002, after buying a 36-year-old, 1,800-square-foot fixer-upper, this young couple put on their tool belts and got to work. "It was, for lack of better words, just terrible," says Elizabeth. "It had no flooring, the previous owners were smokers, the front door wouldn't open, the air conditioning was nonfunctional and the roof was leaking."

The couple gutted the kitchen, removed walls to improve the floor plan, remodeled all three bathrooms and installed a roof and new electrical wiring. Three years later, they finished the house and their most important project -- the addition of daughter Kirsten Elizabeth to their family.

But one day Elizabeth looked around and wondered about the limits on their homeowners policy, which was based on the condition of the house when they bought it, leaks and all. "I guess it had to do with the hurricanes in Florida," says Elizabeth. "We've had hurricane threats, but we haven't been directly hit since Hurricane David in '79. We've been saying we're blessed, but we're way overdue."

She called MetLife Auto & Home and was shocked when calculations showed that the cost to rebuild her house was more than double the limit on her existing policy, which was with a different insurance company. Increasing her house's limit in turn bumped up her contents limit, which is typically estimated at 50 to 70 percent of a building's value. "If I'd had a fire, I'd have been completely out of luck," she says. "It could have destroyed us."

Every day there are more people like the Rays in the home improvement center aisles. According to the Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard University, American homeowners spent $176 billion on home remodeling in 2003. Record-low interest rates have helped fuel the home improvement craze.

Potential Problems. When home improvements aren't reported to the insurance company, your home may be left undervalued and underinsured. If you've kept quiet to save on your premium, that plan would backfire: In the event of a disaster such as a fire, all your hard work may literally go up in smoke, and there might not be enough money for the improvements to be covered.

"Underinsurance has become a front-burner issue," says Robert P. Hartwig, chief economist for the Insurance Information Institute (III). He says that awareness of underinsurance has grown because of "major natural disasters -- such as the recent wildfires in California or Hurricane Katrina -- and tales of people's recovery, which has been impaired because of inadequate insurance in many cases."

Smart Solutions. Once a year, do a policy review with your insurance representative or agent. They can calculate how much it would cost to rebuild your house -- including that upgraded master bath and gourmet kitchen -- then make sure your insurance policy covers you for 100 percent of that amount. "When you buy a car, the first thing you do is call your insurer because you can't drive a car without it," says Hartwig. "But when many people spend the equivalent of a new car on their home, they don't call their insurance company. That's a prescription for disaster."

THE BEEN-THERE-FOREVER NEIGHBORS
When Teresa Hoopman of Hastings, Minnesota, built her custom home back in 1987, she was instantly smitten with the property. "It's location, location, location," says Teresa, who retired in 2004 and married her true love, Dale. "I overlook the bluffs of the Mississippi and can see the river." More than 18 years after moving in, she's amazed at the recent surge in real estate prices: Several houses in her neighborhood have sold for more than $400,000.

With prices soaring, Teresa wondered if her house was underinsured, especially because she hadn't updated her policy in years. Teresa isn't alone: Almost 40 percent of Americans haven't updated their homeowners policies within the last three years, according to a 2004 poll conducted for the Insurance Information Network of California. Although Teresa's policy review with MetLife Auto & Home showed that she was properly insured, other homeowners discover problems not because of their home's higher market value but because of today's higher costs of construction.

Potential Problems. If the last time you looked at your homeowners policy was when you bought your house, chances are that the limits on your policy haven't kept pace with current construction costs, which continue to rise. Take this example from III: A house purchased 10 years ago and insured for $100,000 would cost $134,000 to rebuild today, assuming a modest 3 percent annual inflation rate in costs.

The super-heated real estate market does bear an important reminder: The insured value of a house is not the same as its market value. "People need to understand that they're insuring their home for rebuilding or replacement -- not the land -- and that land is what's driving up real estate costs in this day and age," says Hartwig. He says it used to be common practice to insure a house for 80 percent of the purchase price. "That's gone out the window, because the land has become more of a share of the value." What does that mean to you? A house that is located in southern California where land is scarce may sell for $750,000, but the actual cost to rebuild it may be only $400,000.

Smart Solutions. When you do your policy review, add an inflation guard clause to your policy. This automatically adjusts your policy each year to keep pace with construction costs in your area. Also ask if your policy offers replacement cost, which covers the cost to rebuild your house. Policies that offer actual cash value are less expensive, but they will only reimburse you for the depreciated value of your house, and that will never be enough to rebuild from scratch.

THE OLD-HOUSE LOVERS
The appeal of the 1930s Chicago-area bungalow was clear to newlyweds Michelle Ziemba and Steve Wascher, who bought their first house five years ago. "It has great wood floors, crown moldings and stained-glass windows in the living room," says Michelle. "The appreciation has gone up so much that we were able to refinance and get rid of our private mortgage insurance. We've refinished all the floors, redone closets, renovated the kitchen and replaced windows, and we did a big plumbing job last summer."

Although Michelle was sure that her policy was out of date, a review by MetLife Auto & Home showed that her house had adequate coverage.

Potential Problems. Older homes, especially if they are historic, present unique insurance challenges. Often, these homes feature better craftsmanship and higher-quality materials than those used in homes built today. And details such as high-grade wood floors or an elaborately detailed and painted Victorian wood exterior can be much more expensive to replace than modern vinyl tile and siding. That's why it's important to discuss unusual architectural details with your insurer and make sure there is enough insurance to cover their replacement.

Smart Solutions. Calculating the cost to rebuild a house is as easy as multiplying the local building cost averages per square foot times the number of square feet in a house. But that's far from the entire story. Tell your insurance company about the presence of items such as wood floors, high-end wall coverings and custom windows.

Owners of older homes also should consider ordinance or law coverage. It covers the added costs of bringing an old home up to current building codes and laws, if necessary. So if that 1920s Craftsman house doesn't have a foundation that's up to code, this coverage pays to get it there.


DO A FREE HOME CHECKUP TODAY
Whether or not you currently have your homeowners policy with MetLife Auto & Home, you can benefit from a policy review. The review will take about 20 minutes, and the customer service representative will determine the proper cost to rebuild your home. You'll want to have the following information on hand:

  • Year built
  • Square footage
  • Interior wall finishes (drywall, knotty pine or tile, for example)
  • Floor finishes (carpet, wood, ceramic, etc.)
  • Recent upgrades · Number of bathrooms
  • Roof type (slate, composite, shingles, etc.)
  • Anything that makes your home unique, such as arched windows, hand-carved moldings or ornate fireplaces

MetLife Auto & Home is one of the few insurance companies that offers replacement cost settlement (Coverage A Plus*), which covers the full cost to repair or rebuild your house. MetLife Auto & Home also offers inflation guard protection. Ask about these additional coverages when you have your policy review or speak with your MetLife Auto & Home agent or representative for details, or call 1-800-GET-MET1.

*Available in most states.


GET THE ADVANTAGE WITH METLIFE AUTO & HOME
FEWER WORRIES WITH COVERAGE A PLUS!
With MetLife Auto & Home's Coverage A Plus, your homeowners coverage automatically equals the replacement cost of your home at the time a claim is made. That's true even if that cost exceeds the limit of liability shown on the declarations page. You have less to worry about in the event of a disaster because your insurance will cover the current cost to rebuild your home. MetLife Auto & Home is one of the few insurers to offer this valuable coverage. In addition, all of our home, condo and renters policies include Inflation Protection to keep your coverage in line with rising building costs.

Related Links

Quick Links


Special Offer!
Enjoy FREE SHIPPING and a special low price on Home Improvement 1-2-3 -- with 560 pages and 340 projects from the experts at The Home Depot. You pay only $19.99, plus applicable tax. Call 800-678-8091 and mention "MetLife" to take advantage of this special offer.

MetLife Auto & Home®
MetLife Auto & Home is a brand of Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company and its Affiliates, Warwick, RI

Copyright © 2003-2008 Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company NY, NY - All Rights Reserved - E00014KVV MLIC-LD

Privacy Policy